An Unexpectedly Genocidal Hobbit

J.R.R. Tolkien’s 1937 novel The Hobbit stands out as a story for older children. Peter Jackson’s just-released film does not.

hobbitIn my ‘tween years, the tale told in the voice of a hobbit, a humane though not human creature, offered a humor-laced journey through Middle Earth, an imagined world at once arcane and familiar. (photo credit) A standalone delight, it also drew me in to more Tolkien works – the well-known Ring trilogy, of course, as well as the little-regarded Silmarillion. Years after, these latter tomes defied read-aloud attempts, even as The Hobbit served as a beloved bedtime book for my child.

Jackson’s The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey is a different story altogether. Early on in the film, the hobbit’s voice is replaced by an all-seeing 3D eye that is prone to abrupt shifts in scene. Lost is the hobbit’s wondering focus. Lost too is much humor, save for food fights and the sort of snot jokes that serve as Hollywood staples these days.

Unutterably lost is the humaneness that the hobbit brought to The Hobbit.

The film’s characters speak often of “adventure,” yet they seem only to have one kind: Combat, repeated, and repeated, and repeated, over the 166 minutes of the movie. This is no child’s combat, either. There is much wielding of swords, much crunching of bones, much slicing of flesh. The wizard Gandalf shows viewers a nonchalance – almost a wink – as he beheads a goblin. A film orc unknown to the novel exhorts his troops to destroy every last dwarf.

These celebrations of violence, this call to genocide, appear stripped of moral content. No character wrestles with his choice to kill, none feels remorse after wreaking harm. Though the lethal power of avarice and the blinding lure of othering are much on display, nothing invites the viewer to consider, to judge these characters, let alone to reflect on the presence of these evils on the real Earth.

In this month of reflection on violence, however, such consideration is in order – by those who made this Hobbit, and by the patrons, old and young, who have made it the world’s #1 film.

One thought on “An Unexpectedly Genocidal Hobbit

  1. I can only imagine how appreciative JRRT would be knowing you are challenging this portrayal of his work. Thank you from an old patron.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s